Jump to content

Island Games team


braveheart
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 65
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

i would have alan duncan in my team but he no longer lives in the island as for joe leask ahead of ross macdougall thats just made my day al be laughing all day about that one,

 

Yes, that's your opinion.

 

Here is another one of your opinions. This one was regarding the Player of the Year.

 

in my eyes there only one winner, he has been da driving force in the delting and shetland midfield and made a mug of many of the top players in the league ladies and gentlemen mr alan duncan

 

I am not sure if they have a top three or not ? If so, was Alan even in the top three ?

 

 

 

ok alan duncan didnt win player of the year probley because he was missing at the start of the season i also said merv jamieson should have been considerd, many people i spoke to felt the same thats taking nothing away from ross moncrieff who did have a good season

 

the leask macdougall debate

1,physically joe leask is not aswell built and gets pushed around and bullied of the ball were as ross macdougall is bigger and stronger if you were to ask any center-half in shetland am sure they would rather play against joe leask as you could domanite him especially in the air

 

2.maybe bar this season as he was mostly injured ross macdougall has the better goalscoring record through the seasons (to be fair joe leask is younger)

 

3,Ross Macdougall has a better work rate as he will run all day which suited the system that we played for the last 4 or 5 years

 

but i am not saying he is a poor player!! i just cant see the reasoning for picking joe leask ahead of ross macdougal if it were a forward 2 i see the point but i would still say you have 3 or 4 better strikers than joe leask although i think he is more of a wide man as he is a very skillfull player

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the leask macdougall debate

1,physically joe leask is not aswell built and gets pushed around and bullied of the ball were as ross macdougall is bigger and stronger if you were to ask any center-half in shetland am sure they would rather play against joe leask as you could domanite him especially in the air

 

2.maybe bar this season as he was mostly injured ross macdougall has the better goalscoring record through the seasons (to be fair joe leask is younger)

 

3,Ross Macdougall has a better work rate as he will run all day which suited the system that we played for the last 4 or 5 years

 

but i am not saying he is a poor player!! i just cant see the reasoning for picking joe leask ahead of ross macdougal if it were a forward 2 i see the point but i would still say you have 3 or 4 better strikers than joe leask although i think he is more of a wide man as he is a very skillfull player

 

Thanks for your response - nice to see someone able and willing to back up their opinions with something they've taken the time to think about.

 

As to the two players...you seem to be suggesting that they're different types of player so it's maybe trying to compare apples with oranges anyway.

 

In any case, surely it would be up to the manager to decide who should play and for him (or her) to decide on the tactics to be used depending not only upon each team members' strengths but on finding the blend that makes a team.

Remember the team may not include the 'best' eleven players in Shetland.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

that is true 2 players like that may play in the same postion but are completly diffrent players

 

any news on the new manager yet? seems to have gone cold av only heard 2 names mentiond latly myself which is john jamieson and robbie simpson ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
 Share


×
×
  • Create New...