Jump to content

Seal Slaughter


nederlander
 Share

Recommended Posts

Is this thread about the actions of Mr. Stewart or the ethics of seal culling?

On this point, in a totally natural system, before man came along, there would have been a natural balance to the oceans food chains. Killer whales at the top with seals, dolphins and porpoises on the next rung, then larger fish, small fish etc right on down to the plankton and other microscopic organisms at the bottom.

 

Then man comes along and starts messing with things, particularly at the top of the chain where whalers devastated the killer whales allowing the seals and others to multiply, increasing their predation of organisms further down the chain (Not to mention man's pressure on the rest of the chain).

 

So without the top predator, should man be taking his place and controlling seal numbers instead?

 

There's an interesting parallel in the case of fox hunting. In the natural landscape fox numbers were kept in check by wolves, big cats and bears (that's why foxes live in burrows). Then man came along and removed the wolves, bears and big cats allowing the fox population to increase, impacting on all the smaller animals (not to mention livestock) so man invented fox hunting to control fox numbers.

 

So the question is: Should man be controlling the numbers of wild animals in cases where man has removed (or severely depleted) the top predators which would have normally fulfilled this purpose?

 

Discuss.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 628
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Guest Anonymous

I know somebody will correct me, but I've never heard of the Killer Whale being hunted.. Even the nasty Norskies never hunted Orcas..

 

So saying that man, by killing whales, has allowed the seal population to rise, is a completely erroneous statement.

The only reason that seals are multiplying is because their natural predator, MAN, is no longer killing them in sufficient numbers.

 

[EDIT] OK, the nasty Norskies did hunt them once they had butchered all the other whales,,,, I've just read Wikipedia's page,, :oops: ..

But, MAN is still the selkies natural predator. :wink: [/EDIT]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

^ I hadn't heard of Orcas being hunted to any extent either, just goes to show.

 

And, despite the fact that people didn't eat the meat, seals were historically hunted here for their pelts and oil, before it became illegal. Even by youngsters (Read Edmonston).

 

But, to throw in another emotive ethical angle. All whale species*, apart from Orcas, are consuming food that could profit man. Should we start culling them again too?

 

*Even the filter feeders, as they are consuming plankton that fish could eat, and that we could subsequently catch

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let alone the continual reference to different ways of killing seal pups... It is unacceptable!!

 

That's a little bit out of context if you read my earlier post. I in no way condone this act; I only wanted to point out that there are more humane methods. And quite rightly, as crofter mentioned in reply to my post, it is illegal, as I believe it should be.

 

jeez, spelling and grammar; I guess I was in windows start up mode this morning--a bit slow to boot up :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Anonymous

But, to throw in another emotive ethical angle. All whale species*, apart from Orcas, are consuming food that could profit man. Should we start culling them again too?

 

Naughty Njugle,, :wink:

Don't get me started on the killing of whales. It's the only thing I hate about Norway.

Anybody who harms a whale should be strung up by the gonads. :twisted:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And, despite the fact that people didn't eat the meat, seals were historically hunted here for their pelts and oil, before it became illegal. Even by youngsters (Read Edmonston).

 

Or more recently;

 

http://www.booksfromscotland.com/Books/Bombs-Boils-Brushes-9781904746379?view=viewCover

 

But, to throw in another emotive ethical angle. All whale species*, apart from Orcas, are consuming food that could profit man. Should we start culling them again too?

 

The norwegians never stopped!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is this thread about the actions of Mr. Stewart or the ethics of seal culling?

 

I like trees. I bet that hill behind my house could be covered with trees if it weren't for all the sheep. Well, lots of sheep get killed in Shetland every year so I suppose it would be alright if I went up there with a fence post and whacked all the sheep on the head.

 

I don't think so. There are certain ways things should be done and folk can't just go around doing whatever they feel like willy-nilly without accepting the consequences.

 

yet anidder idiot jumping on the band wagon,if you like trees eff off to the new forest

Link to comment
Share on other sites

yet anidder idiot

 

Thanks, love you too. x

 

jumping on the band wagon,if you like trees eff off to the new forest

 

I'm not sure which bandwagon I've inadvertantly hopped on today but I'm not actually against the culling of seals when done in the correct and appropriate regulated manner. However, if someone wants to take it upon themselves to smash in the heads of anything living, be it mice, kittens or seals, I do object and have every right to.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

yet anidder idiot jumping on the band wagon,if you like trees eff off to the new forest

 

Further to Khitajrahs own reply, it might be said that you are jumping on the bandwagon of encouraging law-breaking sharky, which I'm sure you are not.

 

Not everybody speaking against the crime here is a bleeding-heart liberal tree-hugger. I'd be interested to hear how his wilful law breaking could be defended, rather than how "idiotic" anyone who disagrees with his actions are.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sharkey you do seem to get upset easily. we are allowed to disagree with you.

 

its odd that some folks that hate seals are in love with whales. did the old folks not treat them as fish in the past.

 

why do you think its OK to cull seals in js manner but if you were to see a group of people slaughtering a pod of whales as in the faroes would they be happy.

if we were to allow the unrestricted hunting/clubbing of marine wildlife there would have been none left. the people in the past did indeed hunt and kill the wildlife but they also helped them breed. if they had not how many otters would there be.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whaling_in_the_Faroe_Islands

 

no its not just about this guys actions its about wildlife protection. its odd that the pro whacker have support in the tree hugging community they are opposed to the seal laws as well. admitted they do want it banned completely. that is a possible outcome of illegal seal killing. which would stop the fish farmers from protecting there cages.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

khitajrah

when you mention hitting mice over the head. i take it you don't have a mouse issue. you do need to be careful with these big killers of the skirting board. if we don't control them we would end up knee deep in fur. maybe that could be a new industry mouse skin coats.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

can anyone tell me how to hell killing cats,sheep,mice,trees,whales,over fishing etc,has anything to do with this man's obvious stupid mistake,,it's done,he's been handed his sentence,he admitted it fully and did not try to hide anything when he was caught,he chose to keep quiet and accept what was coming to him(apparently there was another issue to this according to some).He stayed away from social occasion after this incident for fear of upsetting people,he recieved hate mail,death threats and effigees of decapitated animals in the post,,,i personally think this issue should be closed but doubt that will happen when our poxy media report it 5 million times a day on sibc and it makes front page when a childs death and court case only warrant a page 5...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sharkey you do seem to get upset easily. we are allowed to disagree with you.

 

its odd that some folks that hate seals are in love with whales. did the old folks not treat them as fish in the past.

 

why do you think its OK to cull seals in js manner but if you were to see a group of people slaughtering a pod of whales as in the faroes would they be happy.

if we were to allow the unrestricted hunting/clubbing of marine wildlife there would have been none left. the people in the past did indeed hunt and kill the wildlife but they also helped them breed. if they had not how many otters would there be.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whaling_in_the_Faroe_Islands

 

no its not just about this guys actions its about wildlife protection. its odd that the pro whacker have support in the tree hugging community they are opposed to the seal laws as well. admitted they do want it banned completely. that is a possible outcome of illegal seal killing. which would stop the fish farmers from protecting there cages.

 

i'm not upset but when someone has to ask if this thread is about mr stewart and then immediately add some comment about killing sheep in order to grow trees as a reference to this case then i think it is a bit ridiculous...the culling o seals has gone on in shetland for years,its nowt new, as is the culling of pilot whales in faroe

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It’s a bit arrogant of the human race oops sorry it’s hu-person these days after all. One can’t put man in front of any letters these days. That we think we are above any other spices on the planet. Just as the dinosaurs had there time and died out or killed of in the ice age, maybe the global warming is the natural order of things and the end of the human race as we know it . Maybe something new will evolve, the political correct spices is on the way or the village of the idiots. But what ever there will be money involved some where

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
 Share


×
×
  • Create New...