Jump to content

School Closures

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 127
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

I have to disagree about closing things. There is such a thing as community. Also a right to live where you want and bring up your bairns there to. It seems again that communities on da Isles get a ra

Does it? Regardless of whose in charge at Westminster the divvy up of whatever money comes to Scotland/Shetland is down to the Scottish Government/SIC, and there's no guarantee that giving either of t

A death by a thousand cuts.....   Close the Secondary School......(Very little incentive for families to settle in Skerries)........Close the Salmon Farm........(More families move out, and some essen

Shetland Times reports Dr Wills as furious, SO WHAT.


Skerries Secondary School was closed by FALSE information ( being polite)

YOU have saved NOTHING Dr Wills, so be a real man, come to Skerries and look us all in the eye (as promised Nov 2013)and tell us you stick by your closure vote.


We have seen no evidence of educational gain, or financial savings. ( FACTS)


Dr Wills can you show any savings of closing Skerries Secondary? Prove it, otherwise stay furious.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 months later...

best to complain to Scottish education minister. we all know what they intend to do. its not changed. there goal  is still to shut all junior high schools.

Except that the Education Department should not have goals like that.  Their goal ought to be to follow the directions given to them by their political masters to the best of their ability.  And frankly if they would rather not do what the councillors tell them then resignation might be the best option.

Link to post
Share on other sites

^ Yes, but, when their political masters tell them to cut costs and tell them to become compliant with a new education policy handed down from their political masters in Edinburgh, but without giving clear instruction as to how those ends should be achieved, widespread closures are inevitably going to end up being on the table along with other options.


Don't get me wrong, I'm not siding with the Education Department even though it may seem that way. Political masters need to give clear and reasonably precise directions to their minions, or chaos, as we see right now, ensues. As I see it, there's fault on both sides, not least perhaps in the Legal Department, who, if the claims made in the linked article are accurate, should have advised their political masters that halting a consultation and setting it aside until such time as they decided to revisit it, was in fact illegal.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Skerries folks were attacked 2 years after their previous consultation... The last and final consultation took place when there was no Headteacher in place...


Do you think the SIC is interested in the law or indeed in the damage caused by their consultations to both the bairns and the community?


Is Mrs Budge surrounded by the right team of people?


Are they really seeking legal advice?


And in your opinion, is their real aim the evaluation of the quality of the education provided by rural schools or is it a simple erasing exercise to get small schools out of the Shetland map and off the financial books?

Link to post
Share on other sites

^ The SIC is a wholly broken organisation, it continues by its own momentum despite itself, there is nobody at the wheel, nor is there rhyme, reason or a plan, only a few front line folk trying to do the best they can with whatever crap happens to fall from aloft. Any few "good" people which might still exist up through the system are either strangled in red tape or lost in the morass of numpties which surround them - a total wipe out of "managers" and management structure is needed and start over again from a clean page. Until that happens it can only bumble on like a multi-headed dinosaur that doesn't have a clue, creating chaos with ever step, that nobody can explain, justify or unfortunately prevent.

Edited by Ghostrider
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 9 months later...

A death by a thousand cuts.....


Close the Secondary School......(Very little incentive for families to settle in Skerries)........Close the Salmon Farm........(More families move out, and some essential workers)..............Skerries Flights No longer SAFE as the short runway needs Firecrew..........(Now we have less options of travel)........Dr probably wont waste a whole day visiting Skerries........


I expect Skerries will now need major reinvestment to make the place viable again........Nice one Dr Wills you deceived your fellow councilors with your emotive speech, aided by the inept Education bullies.


Dr Wills, Gerry Edwards, Vaila Wisheart, Audry Edwards, and a few others DECEIVED the SIC, you saved NOTHING in closing the SKerries Secondary School, if anything you have increased the costs


FACTS are the primary school now, is running at the same cost as when both Secondary,and Primary School was open.


If any of the names above had any HONOUR they should resign for telling LIES.


SAVING £73000


Skerries are still waiting for DR Wills to look us all in the eye.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It and other schools that are not vilable should be closed for the greater overall good.

The real issue here is WHY are school roles falling? I see the Skerries school as the thin end of the wedge, if you follow the logic of closing small schools to favour large ones then it will carry on this endless cycle of depopulation and centralisation. 


People also forget that most of Shetlands wealth is generated by the rural areas NOT by Lerwick. I don't know figures for what Skerries puts in to the economy in taxes etc but I would be willing to bet it is more than £73k per annum. 


The Whalsay Secondary School will probably be targeted again soon, a thriving community which contributes greatly to the economy of Shetland (and the wider country) yet it is not safe from these misguided and draconian cost saving exercises which will almost certainly cost more in the long run. 


One of the reasons I joined Wir Shetland is to help try to reverse this worrying trend. Our rural areas need development and support NOT cuts and depopulation. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...